Why all Jews should skip the next Women’s March




The Women’s March made me uneasy from the begin.

First, I questioned the place the Jewish leaders had been. After all, Jewish ladies have traditionally performed distinguished roles in second-wave feminism. Where had been this technology’s Betty Friedan or Gloria Steinem? The omission of Jewish ladies in management roles was ominous, and as I realized over the coming months, my emotions had been justified.

The first Women’s March, held in January 2017, omitted Jews from its listing of so-called “Unity Principles” — minority teams whose rights they had been making it their mission to guard. It was a evident oversight contemplating that for years previous to Trump’s candidacy, the FBI reported that Jews had been on the receiving finish of extra reported hate crimes (56.8 p.c) than different spiritual teams, properly forward of Muslims (16.1 p.c), who had been included in the rules.

The Women’s March rapidly turned a monument to intersectionality — a matrix of marginalized teams becoming a member of forces to struggle a typical enemy in the type of the cis-gender white male, in any other case often known as the patriarchy and personified in Donald Trump. But whereas Jews make up simply 2 p.c of the American inhabitants and are targets of rising hate crimes on each the proper and the left, the Jewish religion — and by extension, Israel — is inexplicably thought of by march leaders to symbolize the zenith of energy.

This is why, as I predicted, none of the audio system at the first Women’s March spoke about the safety of Jews. Yet, different audio system, like Angela Davis, known as for a free Palestine. And amongst photographs from the occasion, I noticed a younger girl holding up an indication that learn: Free Birth Control and Palestine! It was the good instance of how marchers wrongly conflate ladies’s rights with a hatred of Israel.

In reality, Jews have lengthy been at the forefront of the ladies’s rights motion. The oral contraceptive capsule was developed by Dr. Gregory Goodwin Pincus, a Jewish biologist and researcher recruited by Margaret Sanger when she met him at a Planned Parenthood profit in 1951. That was my Uncle Goody, and with out him the invention of the Pill and reproductive rights in America would doubtless have had a later begin.

Betty Friedan’s “The Feminine Mystique” was the seminal work that ignited second-wave feminism. Bella Abzug was the first Jewish girl elected to Congress, whose first vote was in help of the Equal Rights Amendment.

The first Women’s March was simply the starting of my issues. A couple of weeks later, the International Women’s Strike, co-sponsored by the Women’s March, included “Justice for Palestine” amongst the causes that “are . . . the beating heart of this new feminist movement.” One of the eight promoters of this occasion was Rasmea Odeh, a terrorist convicted for her function in two bombings in Jerusalem in 1969, considered one of which killed two faculty college students. (Odeh has since been deported to her native Jordan.)

Linda Sarsour, the Palestinian-American co-chair of the Women’s March, is obvious about her stance on Israel. In 2017, she informed The Nation Zionist couldn’t name herself a feminist.

But once I posted my issues on my Facebook web page, they had been rejected as now not related to the rapid crises of the Trump period. When I shared my issues about anti-Semitism in the Women’s March management, together with their unwavering help of Nation of Islam chief Louis Farrakhan, I used to be informed I wanted to be schooled in anti-blackness.
According to a current investigative report for Tablet Magazine, deep-seeded anti-Semitism was apparent from the very first assembly between march organizers, with Carmen Perez and Tamika Mallory reportedly refusing to incorporate Jewish ladies in management positions as a result of, they alleged, Jews bear the “collective responsibility as exploiters of black and brown people.”

Now that we all know the reality about the leaders who refuse to step down, I name on my fellow Jews to skip the third Women’s March, on Saturday, Jan. 19, and as a substitute be part of me in celebrating Shabbat. American Jews should unite in what connects us as Jews — and never march with those that divide us as Americans.

Melanie Notkin is the creator of “Otherhood: Modern Women Finding a New Kind of Happiness.” In 1997, she performed a key function in the launch of NJOP’s Shabbat Across America. The 23rd annual occasion is March 1, 2019.




Be the first to comment on "Why all Jews should skip the next Women’s March"

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*