Refugee government order undermines our values and fails to make us safer.

I grew up in Atlanta however now dwell in New England. Since final Sunday, my social media exchanges with Atlanta associates have centered on the upcoming Tremendous Bowl. However one thing has occurred that’s larger than the Falcons and the Pats, larger than Crimson states and Blue states.  It’s basically about American values and in addition the safety of those United States, no matter the place we dwell, how we voted or what workforce we’re rooting for.

On Friday, President Trump issued a new government order on refugees.

To evaluate the brand new coverage, I ask three questions:

  • Is it based mostly on info?
  • Will it make us safer?
  • Is it per long-held American values?  

The president lately advised ABC Information that we’re “permitting folks to come back in who, in lots of instances or in some instances, need to do great destruction. … They’re ISIS. They’re coming underneath false pretense.”

The info say in any other case. A latest research wanting on the dangers of immigration and terrorism concluded that the percentages of being killed by a overseas born terrorist getting into the US are multiple in three million per yr. A terrorist assault by a refugee?  One in three.6 billion. A terrorist assault by unlawful immigrant? One in roughly 11 billion. You might be far, way more prone to be killed by your partner than a terror assault, not to mention an assault perpetrated by a terrorist getting into underneath “false pretense.”

Some may say, “properly, even when the danger is 1 in a zillion, that’s one too many, so why permit any folks in?” That’s an comprehensible response. Nationwide safety professionals will inform you, nevertheless, that there is no such thing as a such factor as zero threat. However let’s set that apart, and take critically the concept we don’t wish to threat even a single further loss of life by terrorism. That brings us to the second query.

Will the manager order make us safer? No. It’s going to really undermine our nationwide safety. Terrorism just isn’t a risk that we will resolve by ourselves. And we will’t merely pull again and conceal. Victory requires the cooperation of our associates, and particularly Muslim international locations – their governments and their residents. The overwhelming variety of victims of terrorist assaults are Muslims. Both we battle this collectively or we lose individually. The chief order will make worldwide cooperation harder, improve animosity in the direction of the US, and strengthen the arms of ISIS to recruit followers and make the case that the US is anti-Islam.

Lastly, we must always ask if the manager order is per American values. It’s not sufficient to say you’re a nice nation. You must act like a fantastic nation. You must put your cash the place your mouth is. On the subject of the Second Modification, many say that it have to be protected even when that comes at a value of 1000’s of individuals killed in gun violence annually. They are saying that some concepts are definitely worth the risks and the prices. So what about different American rules like openness and equity? How is it that we will invade Iraq, unleash chaos after which flip our again on the mess we made and say to households fleeing persecution that “you’re by yourself”?

We anticipate troopers and assist employees, police and medical personnel, and, sure, even common residents to hurry in the direction of the hazard — not run away and depart folks to their destiny. We did that in Boston through the Marathon Bombing. The folks of Boston know a factor or two about terror assaults, however we now have reaffirmed our dedication to accepting refugees.


We are saying America has a particular goal; we are saying we’re a shining beacon. However the government order says America ought to shut the door on youngsters and households. So which is it? Which nation is America, as a result of you possibly can’t have each methods? Are we a rustic of values and rules or a rustic of ugly self-interest and ignorance?

This isn’t about President Trump.  It isn’t about conservatives and liberals or Crimson States and Blue States.  It’s in regards to the American imaginative and prescient and whether or not we –those on watch throughout this second in historical past—have the desire and capability to maintain the American challenge alive.  It’s about patriots, not those enjoying within the Tremendous Bowl towards the Falcons, however actual patriots defending what has justly been known as a very powerful experiment in trendy historical past: the US of America.

Jim Walsh, a senior analysis affiliate on the Massachusetts Institute of Know-how’ Safety Research Program, was director of Harvard College’s Managing the Atom challenge. 

You may learn various opinions from our Board of Contributors and different writers on the Opinion entrance web page, on Twitter @USATOpinion and in our every day Opinion e-newsletter. To submit a letter, remark or column, test our submission tips.

Learn or Share this story: http://usat.ly/2jEQBig