What is Urban Meyer’s legacy at Ohio State? Depends on which side you ask | NCAA Football

COLUMBUS, Ohio — The twin nature of City Meyer’s tenure at Ohio State was summed up in a single query at his Tuesday information convention asserting his retirement on the Fawcett Heart. 

Would his suspension through the 2018 season, primarily based on his data and dealing with of the Zach Smith home abuse scandal, have an effect on his teaching legacy?

Meyer provided a deliberate two-part reply.

MORE: OSU’s Playoff standing? For as soon as, it isn’t difficult

“That is a couple of very sturdy program and a gaggle of gamers that simply received back-to-back (Huge Ten) championships,” Meyer mentioned. “The legacy is: You may solely management a lot. I can mislead you and say that is not vital to me. Any human being, that is vital to you, and other people may have their opinions. Simply do the most effective to do issues the correct method.”

That cuts to the guts of Meyer’s legacy courting to his tenure at Florida, which is fiercely debated by his supporters and detractors. Meyer managed the narrative on the sector with nationwide titles and numerous success tales, however he additionally leaves after that scandal necessitated — to some — that three-game suspension.

To his supporters, Meyer is the tragic hero who battled well being points to guide the Buckeyes to a different Huge Ten championship, two spots wanting one other berth within the School Soccer Playoff. Meyer’s final recreation can be on the Rose Bowl, the primary time he has coached within the “Granddaddy of Them All.” It is going to be the final time he’ll coach at Ohio State, the place he has compiled an 82-9 document (54-Four in Huge Ten), a 7-Zero mark in opposition to rival Michigan — together with a 62-39 drubbing on Nov. 24 — and the 2014 nationwide championship.

In fact, the Meyer legacy has its detractors. There’s his dealing with of the Zach Smith scandal, sure, however there’s additionally the actual fact his retirement from Ohio State partly resembles his exit from Florida after the 2010 season. Meyer, citing well being causes and a want to spend extra time along with his household, left that program with a number of systemic points earlier than taking on at Ohio State in 2012.

This time, Meyer listed well being points stemming from an arachnoid cyst in his mind as a part of an “accumulation” of things resulting in his second retirement, and people detractors will level to Meyer’s extra nebulous reply when he requested if he is performed being a head coach. 

“I consider I cannot coach once more,” Meyer mentioned.

When pressed if he was “pretty sure,” Meyer responded, “I am sure, sure.”

That is classic Meyer, the 54-year-old coach nonetheless leaving simply sufficient wiggle room for hypothesis about his future. There’s one massive distinction in his departures from Florida and Ohio State, nonetheless: Meyer, regardless of two nationwide championships in three seasons from 2006-08, stays typically vilified in Gainesville.

He can be nearly universally beloved in Columbus for his success at Ohio State. That may by no means change. 

“City has a really, very particular reward,” athletic director Gene Smith mentioned through the information convention. “He is an elite coach. His Ohio State groups excel each on and off the sector, and I emphasize off the sector.”

MORE: Timeline of key occasions in Zach Smith scandal

Detractors will say Smith mustn’t have to emphasise the final half. Meyer tried to manage the narrative from begin to end, even when that was inconceivable within the aftermath of firing receivers coach Zach Smith someday earlier than Huge Ten Media Days.

On July 24, Meyer repeatedly denied a report by nationwide author Brett McMurphy detailing alleged home abuse involving Zach Smith and his ex-wife, Courtney. When Meyer was positioned on administrative depart on Aug. 1, Zach Smith defended Meyer in an interview with ESPN. 

“If he loses his job, it is flat flawed,” Smith mentioned. “That is the man who fired me. It might be a criminal offense.”

Meyer’s legacy was additional clouded after Ohio State introduced his punishment on Aug. 24. In that information convention, a dejected Meyer — alongside Gene Smith and college president Michael V. Drake — was requested what he would say to Courtney Smith, the sufferer in the scandal that had come to engulf the Ohio State program:

“I’ve a message for everybody concerned on this,” Meyer mentioned. “I am sorry that we’re on this state of affairs, and I am simply sorry on this state of affairs.”

Meyer backtracked two days later, apologizing to Courtney Smith on Twitter. He returned after the three-game suspension and performed an hourlong information convention the place he displayed the candor that was required at Huge Ten Media Days — however nonetheless left sufficient for his critics to choose aside.  

“If we’re speaking about mendacity to the media, I didn’t mislead the media,” Meyer mentioned. “I didn’t do an excellent job.”

On the sector — as common — the Buckeyes would, for probably the most half, depart little doubt when Meyer returned. They rallied to beat Penn State 27-26 on Sept. 29 in Meyer’s second recreation again for a 5-Zero begin.

Meyer later discovered himself on the heart of extra drama. Defensive lineman Nick Bosa withdrew from faculty the week Ohio State misplaced 49-20 at Purdue on Oct. 20. Meyer’s well being grew to become the main matter because the season wore on. His conduct throughout a 52-51 win at Maryland was over-scrutinized.  

The story wasn’t whether or not Meyer ought to be the Buckeyes’ coach anymore, however whether or not he may be their coach anymore. Meyer and Gene Smith had been having Sunday conversations that started in earnest in November. Meyer mentioned the suspension performed a task in his retirement, but it surely was half of a bigger string of occasions that led to this conclusion. 

“The choice was a results of cumulative occasions, and well being (was) No. 1,” Meyer mentioned. “The truth that now we have an elite coach (Ryan Day) on our workers. The truth that our program could be very wholesome. We have recruited very nicely all performed a big position on this. I am unable to say that is the rationale, that is the rationale, however there are cumulative causes that we’re at this level.”

MORE: OSU nonetheless hasn’t provided entire fact after Meyer media circus

On the sector, Huge Ten champion Ohio State completed 12-1 but in addition missed the Playoff for the second season in a row. Rumors of Meyer’s exit swirled through the remaining weeks.

Meyer took the choice up till this week, then let Gene Smith realize it was remaining. That, after all, led to Tuesday’s relaxed information convention, a far cry from the place coach and athletic director discovered themselves earlier than the season. It provided an introspective Meyer the chance to mirror on his time at Ohio State, his teaching legacy, and the way forward for the Buckeyes program. That included a query about what he would miss most. 

“The gamers,” Meyer mentioned with out pause. “The nice factor is I am hopefully able (that) I do not lose that. I will miss that. I will miss constructing groups. However the gamers, with out query is what I will miss.”

There was Meyer once more controlling the narrative, however that response is open to interpretation: Is that this actually it for him, or is he merely angling for the subsequent job?  If Meyer lands at one other big-time program within the subsequent few years, then this can be gas for many who criticized Meyer’s motives and sincerity in leaving Ohio State. Neither facet will be fully happy with this conclusion.

Regardless of the unhealthy timing and PR missteps through the occasions that led to Meyer’s suspension, it’s vital to recollect the college had no actual incentive to maintain the coach this season if he deserved to be fired. Meyer additionally completed on a excessive be aware with an ideal document in opposition to Michigan and a Huge Ten championship; that complicates either side. 

Meyer was requested yet another time through the information convention about his legacy, and he broke into the query with one other quick-hit response.

“The reality is that you’ve got a soccer coach who has devoted 33 years of my life to the love of student-athletes and never simply on the soccer discipline,” he mentioned. “You speak concerning the unbelievable expertise that you’ve got at a spot like Ohio State, and if you happen to act proper, do proper, you may you could have a job. I — we — assure that. I hope that is our legacy.”

Prefer it or not, Meyer authored his final chapter in Columbus the way in which he needed. On the point of termination and shame, he recovered to guide Ohio State and coach his remaining recreation on the most hallowed place for a Huge Ten faculty. This can be one other legacy recreation for Meyer, and if his monitor document has proven something, then the Buckeyes will in all probability ship their coach out with a win in opposition to 10-Three Washington.  

The supporters will cease and scent the roses in Pasadena, Calif., the crowning achievement of a seven-year tenure at Ohio State. The detractors will stroll over them, sure Meyer can be again quickly sufficient, refreshed and able to construct one other powerhouse in any respect prices.

Each side will consider they’re telling the reality whereas the opposite one is mendacity. That, greater than something, is Meyer’s legacy for now.

Be the first to comment on "What is Urban Meyer’s legacy at Ohio State? Depends on which side you ask | NCAA Football"

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.