MLB trade rumors: Will Marlins trade J.T. Realmuto, baseball's most underrated catcher? -

MLB trade rumors: Will Marlins trade J.T. Realmuto, baseball’s most underrated catcher?

MLB trade rumors: Will Marlins trade J.T. Realmuto, baseball's most underrated catcher?

The Marlins visited St. Louis for a sequence towards the Cardinals final summer time, and earlier than one of many video games I talked with Miami supervisor Don Mattingly about his catcher, J.T. Realmuto.

His eyes perked up.

“Simply seeing his athleticism is particular, places him at that class of the catcher that’s somewhat bit extra the newer catcher, athletic, can run, can just about do every thing,” Mattingly stated. “He’s an attention-grabbing man again there. I believe he’s a man that baseball, basically, will get to know higher over time. I believe he positively ought to have been in consideration (for the All-Star Sport), however while you’ve obtained Posey and Molina …”

MORE: Grading the remaining Marlins by their tradeability

Mattingly completed with a fairly prophetic line. “If he was on the market and accessible, there can be a ton of groups calling about J.T.”

Guess what? J.T. is on the market and accessible. At the least, that’s his hope. The Marlins have already traded away Giancarlo Stanton, Marcel Ozuna and Dee Gordon this offseason, and Realmuto has reportedly requested a commerce.

Why does that matter, you may ask. Right here’s why it issues: J.T. Realmuto simply is likely to be probably the most underrated catcher in baseball. Not underrated by baseball insiders or hardcore followers, after all, however by the informal baseball fan whose information of the Marlins was restricted to Stanton and a shiny home-run construction.

However don’t simply take my phrase for it.

“Oh, he’s ridiculously underrated,” veteran catcher A.J. Ellis, who was Realmuto’s backup in Miami final season, advised me throughout that Cardinals sequence. “I get to see this man first-hand daily, and the very first thing that stands out to me is his athleticism. I haven’t seen an as-athletic catcher as him since Russell Martin first broke in, after I performed with him with the Dodgers. It’s simply his means to maneuver, his means to throw, his means to make use of his athleticism to cowl up any errors that is likely to be in his sport. It’s a novel expertise behind the plate. It’s like having a shortstop or middle fielder taking part in catcher.”

However don’t simply take Ellis’ phrase for it. Right here’s a manner of quantifying that athleticism.

JT Realmuto is baseball’s most athletic catcher on either side of the ball, and it isn’t even actually shut:— Mike Petriello (@mike_petriello) June 28, 2017

Realmuto has been Miami’s main catcher for the previous three seasons. He’s averaged 135 video games a season, with a .281/.323/.430 slash line. In 2017, he popped 17 homers and had 65 RBIs and posted a three.6 WAR, by each Baseball-Reference and FanGraphs formulation. He even has 28 stolen bases over the previous three seasons. Realmuto is arbitration-eligible for the primary time this winter, and he’s not scheduled to turn out to be a free agent till after the 2020 season. Oh, and he doesn’t flip 27 till subsequent spring. So, yeah, you may think about the suitors can be lining up, ought to the Marlins determine to grant his commerce request this offseason, for 3 prime years of Realmuto.

“He’s simply a tremendous expertise, and greater than that he’s a tremendous child and wonderful teammate,” Ellis stated. “He’s a man who involves the sector daily with an expectation that the Marlins are going to win the sport. That’s one thing I respect. I additionally respect the truth that he desires to play each single day. That’s one factor I like in a catcher, sturdiness, and he’s extraordinarily sturdy. He’s the identical man day in and time out, offense and protection. He offers you a high quality sport each time he goes on the market.”

Realmuto is in line to get a wage of round $four million in arbitration for 2018 (primarily based on this estimate by, and if he stays wholesome he ought to see stable jumps in compensation for 2019 and 2020. However make no mistake: If the Marlins determine to commerce Realmuto now, their main aim can be to convey again prospects. This isn’t buying and selling the large wage of Stanton and even the dumping of Gordon’s wage. This must be about restocking the farm system.

So which groups is likely to be ? Let’s have a look.

Astros: Sure, the World Collection champs have each Brian McCann and Evan Gattis below contract for 2018. However Gattis is a free agent after subsequent season, and McCann has a $15 million possibility for 2019 that isn’t essentially appetizing (he’ll be 35 that 12 months). Including Realmuto would offer longer-term stability behind the plate and permit McCann to spend most of his time at DH. They’d should commerce Gattis, however that wouldn’t be too robust.

Diamondbacks: Don’t blame Arizona followers for salivating concerning the concept of Realmuto carrying a D-backs uniform for the subsequent couple of seasons. In the meanwhile, subsequent season’s catching tandem is Jeff Mathis — who turns 35 this spring and hit .215 in 2017 — and Chad Hermann — who hit .181 in 106 video games final season. Realmuto can be a large improve for a staff that can positively be a playoff contender in 2018. The Diamondbacks must do every thing attainable to make this occur.

Nationals: It’s not that the tandem of Matt Wieters and Pedro Severino is unacceptable for the Nationals in 2018. It’s simply that Realmuto can be a reasonably large improve, and it is a franchise taking part in subsequent season with a way of urgency, what with Bryce Harper nearly actually leaving as a free agent after 2018. And having Realmuto for the primary couple of post-Harper years would assist make sure that the Nats stay related in World Collection conversations.

MORE: Rating the highest 101 MLB free brokers for 2018

Pink Sox: Right here’s a fact: If J.T. performed for Boston the previous three years, we wouldn’t should put the phrase “underrated” in any headline about Realmuto. Boston followers would love him (although that’s true for just about any fan base), and he can be an improve on the place. Right here’s the factor, although: Catcher isn’t Boston’s main concern this offseason. The Sox have Christian Vasquez (who hit .290 with a .735 OPS in 99 video games final 12 months) and Sandy Leon (who hit .310 with an .855 OPS in 2016 earlier than regressing in 2017) each below membership management for the subsequent three years, so it’s not like they should do one thing behind the plate.

Angels: This has already been a banner offseason for Angels followers, with the additions of Shohei Ohtani, Ian Kinsler and Zack Cozart, and Realmuto can be a superb capper to a flurry of strikes. In the meanwhile, their catching scenario seems to be like some mixture of Martin Maldonado (.645 OPS, 14 homers in 2017), Juan Graterol (.202 common) and Carlos Perez (.100 common). The most important drawback right here can be discovering an appropriate package deal to ship to the Marlins; the Angels’ system is just about barren, and the one motive they had been in a position to land Kinsler is as a result of Kinsler had no-trade energy, which severely restricted Detroit’s leverage and drove down the prospect value. It is a lengthy shot.

Mets: Realmuto can be an improve on the place, the place Travis d’Arnaud has struggled to remain wholesome (he’s by no means performed greater than 112 video games). But when we’re being trustworthy, does anybody suppose the Mets have the prospects or the fervour to make a commerce like this occur? If the Mets had been critical about contending in 2018, possibly, however don’t guess on it.