Kragthorpe: NCAA redshirt rule is complicated, but watching it play out will be fun

Devonta’e Henry-Cole acquired one carry. Chayden Johnston acquired one kick.

Previously two seasons, every of these College of Utah soccer gamers used a yr of eligibility that was gone right away after a short look in a single sport. That’s unfair. And that’s why the NCAA’s new rule is an enlightened act.

Starting this season, athletes will probably be allowed to play in as many as 4 soccer video games and be counted as a redshirt, retaining a yr’s eligibility within the system that offers them 5 years to play 4 full seasons.

I prefer it, as a result of supplies one other component of faculty soccer for me to put in writing about, observing how coaches handle their rosters. Followers ought to adore it, as a result of they’ll have one fewer factor to fret about in a task that’s traumatic sufficient for them. Coaches ought to embrace it, as a result of they’ll now not need to agonize about whether or not or to not exhaust a participant’s eligibility in a single determined second.

That’s what occurred with Henry-Cole in October 2016, when the Utes had been short-staffed at operating again and he ran as soon as for two yards at Oregon State. Coach Kyle Whittingham would say later, “It’s a disgrace. We hate to waste a yr on a child with with one carry.”

Johnston tried the Utes’ first discipline purpose of 2017, then was changed by Matt Homosexual. He by no means took the sector once more as a freshman. The chance stays for Johnston to redshirt in 2018, and the brand new system would enable him to make an occasional look whereas sustaining three extra years of eligibility.

(Chris Detrick | The Salt Lake Tribune) Utah Utes place kicker Chayden Johnston (12) reacts after lacking a discipline purpose try through the sport at Rice-Eccles Stadium Thursday, August 31, 2017. Utah Utes are main North Dakota Preventing Hawks 17-9 at halftime.

Nothing appears to train followers fairly like these one-time showings that price gamers a yr. It occurred to BYU quarterback Tanner Mangum in October 2016 when he took two kneel-down snaps at Michigan State and, through Twitter, felt compelled to calm followers who had been “freaking out about me ‘burning’ my redshirt.”

Mangum defined he was already 23 and by no means supposed to redshirt that season, which ended with him beginning the Poinsettia Bowl after Taysom Hill was injured.

Ute coach Ron McBride inserted quarterback Alex Smith into an October 2002 sport at San Diego State, principally losing his freshman yr. Ute followers had been outraged; so had been Smith’s members of the family. That subject grew to become moot two years later when Smith entered the NFL draft with one yr of eligibility remaining — as a substitute of two. However his expertise reveals how the brand new rule might come into play.

Coaches may have a number of choices about how one can use these potential 4 video games for a participant. The underside line is that they’ll by no means need to hesitate about deploying anybody, whether or not that’s early within the season in a blowout of an FCS opponent, on a one-play emergency foundation in the midst of the yr or in a bowl sport. Nothing ought to cease them from considering of artistic methods to make use of gamers, or to go deeper into the roster when the starters grow to be worn down late within the season.

Technically, any participant who has not beforehand redshirted is topic to the four-game alternative. The rule might assist an athlete who will get damage in September, for instance, and is ready to come again in November or simply for a bowl sport.

The largest good thing about the rule is retaining younger gamers engaged in this system. In the event that they know they’re accessible to look in a couple of video games throughout what in any other case could be a yr of training and never enjoying, they’re extra more likely to really feel like a part of the crew.

Coaches may have some obligation to make use of all 85 of their scholarship gamers for as much as 4 video games, although. In any other case, those that are overlooked might really feel disenfranchised.

So this factor is barely sophisticated, however I’ll get pleasure from watching it unfold. The rapid software for Utah includes freshman quarterback Jack Tuttle. If he’s the backup to Tyler Huntley, as presumably will occur to start the season, Whittingham and his workers must weigh the worth of enjoying him in some early video games vs. saving him within the occasion Huntley is injured (Jason Shelley, who already redshirted, is also within the QB combine).

(Steve Griffin | The Salt Lake Tribune) Utah quarterback Jack Tuttle fires a move downfield through the College of Utah soccer crew’s first scrimmage at Rice-Eccles Stadium in Salt Lake Metropolis Friday March 30, 2018.

My suggestion could be to make use of Tuttle towards Weber State and Northern Illinois. If he finally ends up being wanted for greater than 4 video games, that will grow to be good use of a yr’s eligibility, anyway.

BYU has much more variables in a four-QB derby, with solely Beau Hoge having redshirted. In any case, there’s no motive to fret initially about how a lot freshman Zach Wilson or sophomore Joe Critchlow performs, and returned missionary Jaren Corridor additionally might get a glance in an occasional package deal of performs as a fifth choice.

What’s bizarre is that even Mangum might play in a couple of video games and nonetheless redshirt, at age 25. But when that occurs, he is perhaps the one who’s freaking out.

Be the first to comment on "Kragthorpe: NCAA redshirt rule is complicated, but watching it play out will be fun"

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*